Understanding Evidence Sufficiency in CMMC Level 2 AssessmentsDuring aCMMC Level 2 Assessment, theLead Assessormust determine whether the evidence collected for each practice issufficientto support an assessment finding. This aligns with theCMMC Assessment Process (CAP) Guide, which requires assessors to evaluate:

Examinations– Reviewing documents, configurations, and system records.

Interviews– Speaking with personnel to confirm implementation and understanding.

Testing– Observing security controls in action to validate effectiveness.

To determine whether evidence issufficient, the assessor ensures that it:

Directly supports the assessment objective.

Demonstrates that the practice is consistently implemented.

Can be independently verified.

Sufficiencyrefers to whetherenoughevidence has been collected to make an accurate determination about compliance.

Option A (Adequacy)is incorrect because adequacy relates tothe qualityof evidence, while sufficiency focuses on whetherenoughevidence exists.

Option C (Process Mapping)is incorrect because process mapping is used for understanding workflows but is not an assessment verification method.

Option D (Assessment Scope)is incorrect because defining the scope happensbeforeevidence collection, during the planning phase.

CMMC Assessment Process (CAP) Guide – Section 3.6 (Determining Sufficiency of Evidence)

CMMC Level 2 Assessment Guide – Evidence Collection and Evaluation

Why Option B (Sufficiency) is CorrectOfficial CMMC Documentation ReferencesFinal VerificationSince theLead Assessor is ensuring enough evidence is available to verify compliance, the correct answer isOption B: Sufficiency.

CMMC Level 1applies toFederal Contract Information (FCI)systems.

Any system or device that is connected to an FCI-handling network is within the assessment scopebecause it canintroduce vulnerabilitiesinto the environment.

TheWi-Fi-enabled thermostat is connected to the FCI network, meaning it haspotential accessto sensitive contract-related data.

PerCMMC Scoping Guidance, this type of device is classified as aRestricted Information System (Restricted IS)—devices that do not store, process, or transmit FCI but areconnected to networks that do.

Restricted IS must be accounted for in the self-assessment scope to ensure they do not compromise security controls.

For a practice to beadequately implementedin aCMMC Level 2 assessment, theresponsible personnel must demonstrate knowledge of deployment, maintenance, and operationof security tools such asantivirus programs. Simply having the tool in place isnot sufficient—there must be evidence that it isproperly configured, updated, and monitoredto protect against threats.

Step-by-Step Breakdown:?1. Relevant CMMC and NIST SP 800-171 Requirements

CMMC Level 2 aligns with NIST SP 800-171, which includes:

Requirement 3.14.5 (System and Information Integrity - SI-3):

"Employautomatedmechanisms toidentify, report, and correctsystem flaws in a timely manner."

Requirement 3.14.6 (SI-3(2)):

"Employautomated toolsto detect and prevent malware execution."

These requirements imply that theperson responsible for antivirus must understand how it is deployed and maintainedto ensure compliance.

?2. Why the Team Member’s Knowledge is Insufficient

Antivirus tools requireregular updates,configuration adjustments, andmonitoringto function properly.

The responsible team member must:

Knowhow the antivirus was deployedacross systems.

Be able toconfirm updates, logs, and alerts are monitored.

Understand how torespond to malware detectionsand failures.

If the team member lacks this knowledge, assessors maydetermine the practice is not fully implemented.

?3. Why the Other Answer Choices Are Incorrect:

(A) Yes, the antivirus program is available, so it is sufficient.?

Incorrect:Just having antivirus softwareinstalleddoes not prove compliance. It must bemanaged and maintained.

(B) Yes, antivirus programs are automated to run independently.?

Incorrect:While automation helps, security toolsrequire oversight, updates, and configuration.

(D) No, the team member's interview answers about deployment and maintenance are insufficient.?

Partially correct but incomplete:Themain issueis that the team membermust have sufficient knowledge, not just that their answers are weak.

Final Validation from CMMC Documentation:TheCMMC Assessment Guide for SI-3 and SI-3(2)states that personnel mustunderstand the function, deployment, and maintenance of security toolsto ensure proper implementation.

Thus, the correct answer is: